Terry Gilbert, it also depends upon where you are. Some folks in some parts of the county or terrain can get your set-up working "well enough," but others hundreds or a thousand miles away will have great difficulty or utterly dismal results. If the Dish 500 reflector could provide consistent good results throuoght the EA foot print, then Cheap Charlie would never have spent all that money of reflectors specifically designed for the EA. I'm just saying, be prepared for your situation with a Dish 500 to be dissppointing, but if it works, then take it as a great reward.