I disagree ... obviously .Compared to the 7 inning doubleheaders and the extra innings “Manfred Man” on second base, I think this is a great idea. The ASG is an exhibition that doesn’t need to be prolonged beyond 9 innings. I’m actually gonna root for a tie to happen. I think having a HR derby settle a tie is kind of a cool thing. If the NHL can settle meaningful regular season games with a shootout, I don’t think it’s crazy for MLB to settle an exhibition game with a HR derby. Just my opinion
I want to see the game of baseball, not Manfords stupid ideas of what can we change next.
The NHL went to hell when the Shootout started to finish games, it's the same thing, lets NOT play the game when it gets to the most important parts.
I mostly quit watching Hockey in 2005 for the most part, even though the Shooot out was already there, its just sad.
Can't wait till we settle the Super Bowl by seeing how many FG's kickers can make in a row.