I use the Square Shooter 2000 (with the amp). My stations are about 25 miles away, and after some pains in finding an adequate spot, I'm receiving fairly well the ones that are transmitting at a decent power.
The only problem with this antenna is that it's highly directional. Point it a few degrees off from the direction the signals are coming from, and it won't nearly get anything... I have one station (PBS) that comes from a direction opposite to the rest, and even though it's the most reliable signal, I don't get it at all if I point the antenna in the direction of the rest of the stations.
So basically, this antenna will work for you if all of your stations are coming from the same general direction.