Haven't gotten to the Dark Knight or Spider-man yet... my top 5 in no special order
1. The Avengers 3D
2. John Carter 3D
3. Underworld Awakening 3D
4. Dark Shadows
5. Abraham Lincoln Vampire Hunter 3D
From there it is hard for me to choose the order. There were a lot of good movies, some for their uniqueness than their box office success. The list would include in box office order, but not my preference order: The advengers, The Hobbit, Looper, Chronicle, Moonrise Kingdom, The Cabin in the Woods, Silver Linings Playbook
I looked through the list and was surprised as to how few really good movies have been out this year. A lot of decent ones, but not a very good year overall.